Rude paper reviews are pervasive and sometimes harmful, study finds

Those reports are not surprising, psychologist Denise Sekaquaptewa of the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor wrote to ScienceInsider in an email. They line up with a lot of findings in the psychological literature on stereotype threat-the psychological harm caused by pervasive negative stereotypes. Essentially, because there are stereotypes that women or people of color are less intelligent or scientifically minded, receiving a review that reinforces such stereotypes-no matter how inaccurate-can create psychological distress. That distress, in turn, can result in self-doubt, impaired performance, and delayed career advancement.